Skip to main content

Happy Anniversary to Cream City Casseroles!

Sing along with me ... 

Happy birthday to us, happy birthday to us, happy birthday Cream City Casseroles! Happy birthday to us!

If Cream City Casseroles was a baby, it'd be eating solid food, toddling around on wobbly legs and blowing out a candle on its first birthday cake.

The launch

I remember launching the business like it was yesterday. After years of dreaming and months of planning, I rolled live the website, leaned back in my chair and let out a huge exhale.

It was officially Out There. 

Starting my own business was, and still is, the scariest and most exciting thing I've ever done. And I'd do it again in a heartbeat.


I am absolutely delighted by how far Cream City Casseroles has come in the past 12 months. Should I name a few highlights from our first year?

  1. Won the People's Choice Award for the Hottest Kitchen Entrepreneur Challenge.
  2. Named Business Partner of the Year by Easter Seals Southeast Wisconsin.
  3. Joined FaB Wisconsin.
  4. Took a refresher business class and met many fellow women business owners/entrepreneurs (a.k.a. my people!) at WWBIC.
  5. Held our first (of many) freezer meal party.
  6. Expanded services to offer customer pick-up at Easter Seals in Waukesha.
  7. Featured on Channel 12 and Fox 6 Studio A.
  8. Included in Metroparent Magazine's list of 7 Successful Mompreneurs.
  9. Featured on
  10. Had our first catering job for the Ronald McDonald House.
  11. Started Donate a Meal option and have to date fed 100+ people in need. 


One of the biggest surprises of the year came when I began getting requests for gift deliveries. It's funny, when I started out, I thought the majority of customers would be busy parents and professionals. I had no idea that the gift dinner aspect would soar to 30-50% of my business.

It's so fun delivering meals to people celebrating joyous milestones. It's also truly humbling to deliver meals to people coping with unimaginable illness, injury and loss. 

We celebrate with food. We comfort with food. We give food to show we care. 

I'm glad Cream City Casseroles makes it easy for people to give food to others.

Thank you!

I'm beyond thankful for our many loyal, repeat customers. Thank you for shopping local. Thank you for your encouragement. Thank you for ... your orders! Please, keep em coming! I'm so happy cooking for you and your families -- and I hope to continue doing so for a very, very long time!

In celebration of our first anniversary and in appreciation for you choosing to shop local, I'm adding a FREE pan of Chocolate Chip Blondie Bars with every March delivery. It's a sweet treat for you, my sweet customers!

- Jess


Popular posts from this blog

Surviving twins

I recently delivered Cream City Casseroles meals to two families with twins.

One was a gift delivery to welcome two precious little babies into the world. As the new dad gratefully accepted the big bag of oven-ready meals, he was visibly moved by his friends' outpouring of love and support.  
We talked for a few minutes about adjusting to life with newborns, and how life with twins is both an incredible blessing and a huge challenge.
"It gets easier," I assured him. "I know. My twins are now teenagers." 
Relief washed over his face.
"This is hard," he admitted. "Really, hard."
Looking back, I barely remember those first few weeks after my girls were born -- they're just a blur. But I do remember being blissfully happy and scared out of my mind, simultaneously.  

A few weeks ago, I got an email from a mom with toddler twins. She travels a lot for work and inquired about ordering meals to stock the fridge for when she's out of town. A…

Knock, knock ... Dinner's delivered!

When I first launched Cream City Casseroles, I only delivered to customers at their daycare centers and workplaces. My main worry was what to do if a customer wasn't home.

We're delivering food here, people!

But then, a customer had a brilliant suggestion:

"What if I left a cooler on my doorstep? You could put my food in there."

Boom. Genius.

You could've heard my forehead slap across town. Why didn't I think of that?

Well, let me tell you, home delivery has TOTALLY taken off. It's the most popular delivery method BY FAR. And it's so simple.

Here's how home delivery works:

1) You leave out a large cooler with ice pack.
2) I put your order in the cooler.
3) I email you that your dinner was delivered.
4) You come home and heat your dinner in the oven.
5) You eat dinner and FREAKING LOVE IT.
6) You immediately order dinner for next week.
7) You reward yourself with a bubble bath ... using the fancy soap.

Just 7 teeny-tiny steps. How easy is that?

I hav…

Dish Delish: Sweet Summer Bratwurst Casserole

I'm a recipe-aholic. I love perusing cookbooks and foodie websites, looking for new and yummy dishes. Wanting to offer some lighter summer options for the upcoming summer months, I've been looking for casserole recipes that can be prepared in the oven, crock pot or grill. 
Tall order, I know, but it can be done. Especially when brats and sauerkraut are involved.

I came across a recipe that is really good, but didn't make the cut for my summer menu. I liked it a lot, but it was too sweet for my chief taste-tester's palate. (My husband.) Still, I thought it was nice for a change and worth sharing.
Sweet Summer Bratwurst Casserole
6 servings
Ingredients: 1 (32 oz.) jar sauerkraut, rinsed and drained3 medium red potatoes, peeled and cut in thin slices1 granny smith apple, peeled, cut in thick chunks1 onion, diced1/2 cup apple cider/juice1/4 cup chicken stock2 TB brown sugar2 tsp caraway seeds1 clove garlic, minced1 lb. brats fully cooked1/2 lb. bacon, cooked, crumbled Combi…